BFMS logo - click for high-res version

Satanic Abuse Claim Highlights Fallacy of ‘Recovering’ Sexual Abuse ‘Memories’

2011-06-13

June 13, 2011, Press Dispensary. Therapists who steer clients towards recovered ‘memory’ of sexual abuse are putting the interests of their clients second to their own beliefs, with devastating consequences, claims a leading psychology academic.

In therapy, when no memory whatsoever has been proffered, the only things that a misguided therapist can feed back are his or her own beliefs about what might have happened
Dr Peter Naish

His comments come at a time when the controversy about ‘satanic abuse’ – reminiscent of the stories from Orkney and Cleveland 20 years ago – has surfaced again, this time following the mysterious death of a former nurse, Carole Myers. The Sunday Times this week* reports that Myers was treated for 20 years by psychiatrists and doctors “who fostered false beliefs in her mind that she was the victim of satanic abuse”.

But Myers is not the isolated case that the article might imply: falsely recovered memory is to this day being treated as ‘proof’ of childhood abuse, despite lack of corroborating evidence and with shattering consequences for the patients and their families.

Dr Peter Naish, Visiting Reader in Psychology at the University of Sussex, states that adults who were victims of childhood sexual abuse might display psychological problems - but that having psychological problems is not a proof of sexual abuse.

He explains: “Some therapists … are convinced that all manner of dysfunctions in adults are clear indications that they were abused.

“This reason is as foolish as the following: “People with malaria have a fever. Mary has a fever so Mary must have malaria”.

“This is a logical fallacy which has destroyed families all over the world”, he  asserts. “And it continues to do so.”

Dr Naish chairs the Scientific and Professional Advisory Board - an autonomous board of advisers to the British False Memory Society (BFMS - http://www.bfms.org.uk ). The BFMS is a charity which was formed in 1993 following reports by accused parents and which is regularly contacted, even nowadays, by parents whose adult children, after receiving therapy or counselling, discover ‘memories’ of having been sexually abused by their parents during infancy**.

Most of these families tell similar stories of a well-educated adult daughter in her late twenties or early thirties suddenly making accusations of severe childhood sexual abuse after undergoing therapy.

Families have been wrecked by the accusations and there have been recorded instances of jail sentences and convictions - which have then been quashed on appeal.

Dr Naish’s comments on Recovered Memory Therapy are made in the current issue of the British False Memory Society Newsletter***. In an article described as the ‘BFMS Position Statement on the Recovery of Memory’ he says, “Symptoms do not serve as proof of abuse.”

The Newsletter also carries an article on Carole Myers under the heading: ‘The creation of a satanic myth: an abuse of professional power’.  It has been written by Carole’s brother, Dr Kevin Felstead.

Dr Naish says: “In therapy, when no memory whatsoever has been proffered, the only things that a misguided therapist can feed back are his or her own beliefs about what might have happened…

“Any therapist who persists in guiding clients towards the ‘recollection’ of denied sexual abuse is less interested in the wellbeing of the client than of the wellbeing of his or her pet theory.”

- ends -

Notes for editors
* The Sunday Times, June 12, 2011. Article by Daniel Foggo, p. 18

** Since it was founded in 1993 the British False Memory Society (http://www.bfms.org.uk ) has had contact with more than 2000 families affected by false memory allegations by their now adult children who have ‘discovered’ memories of sexual abuse in early childhood.

*** The full article may be read at http://www.bfms.org.uk/Text_Assets/Position%20Statement%20pdf.pdf

About Dr Naish

Dr Peter Naish B.Sc. Dphil, C.Psychol, MBSECH is a chartered psychologist, Associate Fellow of the British Psychological Society (BPS) and Fellow of the Royal Society of Medicine. He is the Chair of the Scientific Advisory Board of the BFMS.  He was a member of the BPS Working Party set up to develop guidelines for the safe and ethical use of hypnosis. He has acted as Expert Witness at home and abroad where either 'false memory' or the misuses of hypnosis have been issues of concern. He is a Member of the Experimental Psychology Society and the British Society of Clinical and Academic Hypnosis. He is also the Visiting Reader in Psychology, The Sackler Centre for Conscious Science, at the University of Sussex.

The Scientific and Professional Advisory Board to the BFMS

Professor Robert J Audley - Professor Emeritus of Psychology, University College London
Professor Sir Patrick P G Bateson, FRS - Professor Emeritus of Ethology, University of Cambridge
Dr Hamish Cameron FRCP FRCPsych DPM, Consultant Child Psychiatrist, retired
Professor Martin Conway – Professor of Cognitive Psychology, University of Leeds
Professor Hugh L Freeman - Honorary Visiting Fellow, Green Templeton College, University of Oxford
Professor Christopher C French - Professor of Psychology, Goldsmiths College, University of London
Professor Richard Green - Emeritus Consultant Psychiatrist
Mrs Katharine Mair – Retired Consultant Forensic Psychologist
Mr David Morgan - Child, Educational & Forensic Psychologist, Psychologists at Law Group, London
Dr Peter L N Naish – Visiting Reader in Psychology, The Sackler Centre for Conscious Science, Sussed University
Professor Elizabeth Newson, OBE - Professor Emeritus of Developmental Psychology, University of Nottingham
Dr James Ost - Senior Lecturer in Psychology, International Centre for Research in Forensic Psychology, University of Portsmouth
Mr Karl Sabbagh - Writer & Managing Director, Skyscraper Productions
Dr Bryan Tully - Chartered Clinical & Forensic Psychologist, Psychologists at Law Group, London
Dr Kimberley Wade - Assistant Professor of Psychology, University of Warwick
Professor Larry Weiskrantz, FRS - Professor Emeritus of Psychology, University of Oxford
Professor Dan B Wright - Professor of Psychology, Florida International University

For further information, please contact:
Madeline Greenhalgh, director
BFMS
Tel: + 44 (0)1225 868682
Email:
Site: www.bfms.org.uk

Media contacts

Madeline Greenhalgh, director
Tel: + 44 (0)1225 868682
Email:
Site: www.bfms.org.uk

Keywords/tags
recovered memory false memory sexual abuse BFMS satanic abuse

Short permalink:

Images for download
Click on any image to view or download in higher resolution.